Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
PoliticsAzerbaijan

Vatican Sparks Controversy at COP29 Over Gender Rights Negotiations

The Vatican's stance against including gender rights discussions has stalled crucial climate change support for women at the UN's COP29.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Vatican Sparks Controversy at COP29 Over Gender Rights Negotiations
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

At COP29 in Azerbaijan, the Vatican, in alliance with several conservative nations, has blocked provisions aimed at supporting women affected by climate change, highlighting a broader global backlash against gender and LGBTQ+ rights in such negotiations.

The Vatican's Secretary of State, Pietro Parolin, representing Pope Francis at the UN COP29 climate conference, has drawn criticism following the Vatican's decision to oppose discussions on women's rights, particularly concerning LGBTQ+ issues. This stance aligns the Vatican with countries such as Saudi Arabia, Russia, Iran, and Egypt, forming a coalition that has obstructed a plan to enhance support for women disproportionately impacted by climate change, as noted by Colombia's environment minister to the BBC.Charities like ActionAid emphasize the urgency for progress, as UN estimates suggest that 80% of those displaced by climate change are women and girls. During this year's COP29 in Azerbaijan, negotiators aimed to update an existing UN action plan, known as the Lima Work Programme on Gender, to ensure that women's experiences and needs are adequately addressed in climate policies. However, the Vatican and its allies have pushed back against the inclusion of the term "gender" due to concerns it could encompass transgender women. This resistance has stalled vital discussions, according to charity representatives and negotiators, with Colombia's Susana Muhamad voicing her frustration at the obstruction of women's rights progress.The decade-long acknowledgment of women's unique burdens in climate crises, often linked to caregiving roles and disrupted reproductive health services during disasters, contrasts starkly with the current negotiations. By 2050, the UN estimates that climate change could expose an additional 240 million women and girls to food insecurity, compared to 131 million men and boys, yet only a minuscule proportion (0.01%) of climate funding prioritizes women-focused initiatives.In the proposed updated plan, African and EU nations sought to recognize the varying impacts of climate change on women, depending on factors like gender, age, and race. The Vatican and its allies' resistance to gender terminology, however, has surprised observers, including Christian charity ACT Alliance's Sostina Takure, who expressed dismay at the Vatican's pivot against human rights language.The continuing gridlock on these discussions has left the future of support for women in climate negotiations in jeopardy, with just days remaining at COP29. Reports indicate that the climate negotiation landscape is currently marred by a backdrop of diminished standards for women's rights and LGBTQ+ recognition globally. Pope Francis, seen as a more progressive figure within the Catholic Church, has allowed certain accommodations for LGBTQ+ individuals, yet the Vatican's overall stance remains firmly traditional, upholding marriage as a union strictly between a man and a woman as articulated in the April document "Dignitas Infinita."The ongoing negotiations lack adequate female representation, with only 36% of last year's negotiators being women. Many activists warn that without diverse voices in these discussions, resulting policies will fail to reflect the realities faced by women in climate-disturbed regions. A recent EU letter signed by 17 nations states that genuine climate crisis responses depend heavily on the empowerment of women and girls across all diversities, underscoring the critical intersection of gender and climate justice.

Topics

More on this story