Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
PoliticsUnited States

Elizabeth Holmes' Fraud Conviction Appeal Denied by Court

The founder of Theranos faces more legal setbacks as her fraud conviction appeal is rejected.

Source: bbc.co.uk1 min read
Elizabeth Holmes' Fraud Conviction Appeal Denied by Court
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

Holmes' appeal challenged the legitimacy of trial evidence but was unanimously dismissed by the Ninth Circuit Court.

In a significant blow to her case, Elizabeth Holmes, the former CEO of the failed blood-testing startup Theranos, has lost her appeal against her conviction for fraudulent activities. Sentenced to over 11 years in prison, Holmes sought to overturn her conviction by questioning the validity of trial evidence and testimonies. Central to her appeal was the testimony of Ramesh "Sunny" Balwani, her ex-business associate and romantic partner, arguing that his statements regarding his responsibility for Theranos' financial practices should have been considered. Balwani, who received a prison sentence of more than 12 years, also had his appeal rejected.The Ninth Circuit Court, presided over by Judge Jacqueline H Nguyen, firmly dismissed Holmes's claims, calling Theranos's ambitious assertions about conducting blood tests with a simple finger prick “nothing more than a mirage.” The judge's opinion articulated that the boasts made by Holmes and Balwani were not merely exaggerations but rather outright deceit.Holmes was found guilty in 2022 for conspiracy and multiple counts of wire fraud, which involved misleading investors regarding the operational effectiveness and financial stability of Theranos. Balwani, who faced a separate trial, was additionally convicted for defrauding patients.Both defendants challenged a court-mandated restitution payment of $452 million (£358 million) to their victims, a decision the court upheld. Holmes's appeal included objections to expert testimony from former employees and the inclusion of a government inspection report, yet the court found these arguments unconvincing.Theranos, once heralded as a groundbreaking tech start-up with a valuation of $9 billion (£7 billion), faced scrutiny in late 2015 as reports began surfacing about the company's technological limitations. Following a lengthy investigation, both Holmes and Balwani were indicted, leading to convictions that have since turned Holmes’s trajectory from promising entrepreneur to convicted felon. She is currently serving her sentence in a Texas prison, having begun her term in 2023.

Topics

More on this story