In brief
Professor Dr. Salman al-Dayah, a respected Islamic scholar, has made headlines by issuing a significant fatwa that denounces the Hamas-led attack on Israel, an event that has since spiraled into severe conflict in Gaza. This rarely-seen opinion carries weight in a region where Islamic leadership significantly influences public sentiments. His detailed six-page fatwa addresses the consequences of the violence, critiquing the attack for violating essential Islamic principles of jihad.
Dr. Dayah, previously the dean of the Faculty of Sharia and Law at Hamas-affiliated Islamic University of Gaza, argues that the attack disregards critical conditions that govern jihad in Islam—principles that prioritize civilian safety and the humane treatment of innocent lives amidst conflict. Notably, the military incursion on 7 October led to substantial loss of life, with around 1,200 fatalities and numerous hostages captured, prompting a fierce Israeli military response that has resulted in extensive casualties in Gaza, exceeding 43,000 according to local health sources.The scholar emphasizes that actions resulting in excessive civilian casualties are fundamentally at odds with Quranic teachings and the sayings of Prophet Muhammad. He advocates for protecting the well-being of non-combatants and ensuring they receive ample resources during crises. Dr. Dayah's position is notable given his moderate Salafist views, which contrast sharply with Hamas’s more radical ideology.The growing discussion around Dr. Dayah's fatwa reflects broader concerns about Hamas's tactics, potentially leading to divisions within Palestinian social and political discourse on armed resistance against Israel. Despite the dangers surrounding him in northern Gaza, Dr. Dayah chose to remain and fulfill his scholarly duties, a testament to his commitment to Islamic jurisprudence amidst a challenging environment. This fatwa, revealing the internal rifts regarding the legitimacy of armed conflict, is being hailed by observers as a pivotal moment in the ongoing struggle to reconcile Islamic teachings with political and military actions in the region.

