Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
PoliticsUnited States

Trump's Autopen Claim on Biden Pardons Lacks Evidence

A dive into Trump’s assertion that Joe Biden's pardons are void due to being signed with an autopen, revealing the facts behind the claim.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Trump's Autopen Claim on Biden Pardons Lacks Evidence
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

Recent statements by Donald Trump regarding Joe Biden's pardons being void due to autopen usage are debunked by evidence showing Biden signed many documents by hand, reinforcing the legality of these pardons.

Former President Donald Trump sparked a controversy with his recent assertion that many pardons issued by President Joe Biden are void, alleging they were signed with an autopen—a device that replicates a person's signature. This claim, publicized on Trump's Truth Social platform, has not been substantiated by any evidence, and investigations reveal that Biden has indeed signed several pardons by hand.BBC Verify has conducted an analysis, uncovering instances where Biden was photographed signing official documents, including a pardon for those jailed due to marijuana possession. The scrutiny also identified that U.S. governmental records contain consistent presidential signatures in the Federal Register, regardless of the signing method—whether it's Trump or Biden.Trump's claim derives from the Oversight Project, an initiative by the conservative think tank The Heritage Foundation, which contended that Biden's pardons issued on January 19 included autopen signatures. However, there is no supporting documentation or confirmation regarding the exact signatures used for Biden's pardons.Legal experts consulted on the matter have asserted that there are no laws in the U.S. prohibiting the validity of autopen-signed documents, including pardons. Autopen usage is not uncommon; past presidents have employed it for various documents. Andrew Moran, a politics professor, noted that while he expected Biden to sign pardons by hand due to their significance, past administrations have relied on autopen for less crucial documents.A 2005 memo from the Department of Justice acknowledged that a president may legally sign bills without physically doing so, paving the way for autopen use. Moreover, historical precedent illustrates that the revocation of pardons by a president is extraordinarily rare and could plunge the judicial system into convoluted legal battles.Professor Erin Delaney highlighted that a president’s attempt to nullify a predecessor’s pardons would breach unspoken constitutional norms, complicating the situation further if individuals pardoned were to face re-prosecution. Experts emphasize the complexities and precedents that would challenge any attempts to declare pardons void based solely on the signing method.In conclusion, Trump’s claims on social media lack the rigorous legal backing to stand, reinforcing the importance of verifying assertions, especially those implicating presidential authority.

Topics

More on this story